Monday, June 1, 2009

The Signal--Ron Carlson (Book Review)

I can't begin to tell you how I loved Ron Carlson's new novel, any more than I can explain the difference between the Butter Pecan ice cream from Babcock Hall in Madison, Wisconsin and the same flavor anywhere else. If you tasted it, you'd understand. I'll have a sample for you in a minute. (The prose, not the ice cream. Though you can order that delivered, I hear).

In The Signal, just as in Carlson's short stories, a lifetime of emotion is distilled into one event. This time the event is a six-day camping trip in the mountains--a final goodbye for Mack and his ex-wife, Vonnie.

Broken hearted by the death of his father, Mack blew it, big time. Amid the resulting drinking and drug-running, and the threatened loss of his beloved ranch, Vonnie left him. Several months in jail gave him time to dry out and think things over, but not to make a plan. He can just about manage one last annual fishing trip with Vonnie, and despite the fact that she's with another man now, she agrees to go. Big stuff happens on the fishing trip and it doesn't turn out how either of them planned, and that's the story. Six days.

Here's Mack waiting for Vonnie at the beginning of the trip, still unsure of whether she'll show up:
Mack was not scared. He had been uneasy and worried and scared and empty and sort of ruined, and he knew this, but now he had his ways of doing one thing and then the next and it kept the ruin off him. If she left Jackson by four, she'd be along in a while. If she hadn't left Jackson; well then.
An abundance of flashbacks fills in the details of Mack and Vonnie's courtship and how things went wrong. Flashbacks can be tricky business, more distracting than enlightening, but when they work well--as they do here--the result is magic. By the end of Day One while Mack waits for Vonnie to arrive--thirty pages--the reader has tasted enough of his history to be glad to see Vonnie, and to truly understand why his father's death so thoroughly devastated him.
His father's death changed it all. At the ranch everything was tilted, weird; it was more than something missing. Gravity had changed. Mack saw to the horses and painted the small barn, but there was no center for him without his father there.
The setting--the mountains of Wyoming--is as critical to the story as any of the characters are, and the plot becomes riveting at the halfway point. Luckily it's a short book; by the time you can't put it down, you might as well go ahead and finish it.

Some people like ratings; I don't. But if it'll make you read this one, I'll give it five (out of five) glorious pints of Babcock Hall butter pecan ice cream.



The Soundtrack: It's gotta be My Rambling Boy, which Vonnie makes Mack sing so he can't hear her peeing in the woods. Can't find it on Playlist.com but you can click on the song title to hear it at Last.fm.

19 comments:

  1. Good review ... this looks interesting! Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  2. LOL. I love using ice-cream to rate the book. :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Now I want to eat ice cream and read this book! =)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you, Betty & Boo's Mommy and Christina. There are few books worthy of a Babcock Hall ice cream rating but this was definitely one of them!

    Sounds like a good plan, Megan. Just be careful not to drip ice cream on the pages!

    ReplyDelete
  5. That's a very spirited review! When I'm looking for a new adult novel I'll definitely keep this in mind.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks, Summer, I hope you will.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Glad I found your blog through Reading Local.

    This book sounds pretty good -- if I could get my brain around the idea of going camping with an ex-spouse. Sounds like a really bad idea to me.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Rose City Reader, thanks for stopping by! Looks like we'll both be contributors over there.

    The camping-with-the-ex thing works really well in this novel. It was a yearly tradition they both had loved, but their traditions had gotten cut short by everything that went down. This one last trip is like a parting gift to each other. A parting gift rife with tension.

    ReplyDelete
  9. OK, I'll look for this book. and I want the ice cream.

    ReplyDelete
  10. i visited wyoming in 2007 and was smitten in the first 5 minutes. it was like being in a foreign country right in america. (i'm from nj!)

    i can't imagine going camping with someone i split from, but if you say it works, i'll take your word for it!

    you have me drooling over the ice cream, by the way! thanks for the review...i'll add it to mount tbr.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Care. Read the book; come to Portland for the blogger retreat this summer; I'll order the ice cream delivered to share with you.

    Booklineandsinker, I know what you mean about Wyoming! The book will so take you back there! And you don't even have to bring an ex along with you because Carlson provides one you'll want to hang out with for sure. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  12. Wow, I love your ratings system! :-)

    ReplyDelete
  13. Enjoy it for the moment, Marie. I'm not a huge fan of ratings on book reviews, so it will likely be a while before another book gets ice creamed. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  14. This sounds like a really good book. But it's not just the butter pecan that's different - even the Babcock Hall chocolate chip is different than anyone else's! So the real question is, for rating purposes, what would a a Babcock Hall "five" be equal to in say, Breyer's? These rating systems are all so complicated!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Oh, the chocolate chip! Do they still put little pieces of butter brickle in it?

    But yes, Rhapsody, you've hit the crux of the issue, and why I don't like rating systems. I wouldn't trade five pints of Babcock Hall ice cream for any amount of Breyer's, but somebody else might see them as equals. Similarly, a book isn't good or bad, except in how it impacts the reader. Carlson's words speak directly to my heart, but will they speak to yours in the same way? No amount of ice cream (or stars, or whatever) will guarantee that.

    ReplyDelete
  16. This one sounds interesting! Haven't had ice cream in a while. Your post made me want some!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Dang, 3m. I was hoping it'd make you want to read the book!

    ReplyDelete
  18. I don't NEED the ice cream to read this book; however, butter pecan is a favorite . . .

    ReplyDelete
  19. I do hope you'll read it, Gwendolyn, you won't be sorry.

    ReplyDelete